Training in the use of the system takes several days, followed by several months of organizational experience to become proficient in its evaluation style. Job ranking is the simplest and easiest job evaluation method. Hay evaluation method human resources university of waterloo. All jobs in the organisation except teachers, fire fighters and certain jobs in csf soulbury terms and conditions are evaluated using the hay system. General principles about job evaluation the general principles of job evaluation are. Developing hay job evaluation calculator hay job evaluation experience is must. Hay groups job evaluation approach,in fact,is the worlds. Your job description will be submitted to a hayje panel for evaluation.
Job evaluation has its advantages as well as disadvantages, moreover, there is a reason behind every step that takes in a company, so there are many different reasons and factors. In the gcc, the main methodologies used are those of the big consultancies, led by hay, mercer called ipe and towers watson but there are other methods and you could even design your own grading approach, based on criteria that are specific to your organisation. It is the most common job evaluation system in all areas of activity private, public. Job evaluation is a process to determine the value of a particular job to the organization based on the importance of. Provide an explanation and critique of each approach, identifying the relative strengths. This manual is not intended to be a training manual to prepare individuals to be job evaluators or to be a definitive resource on job evaluation methodology. Hay job evaluation is a method used by corporates and organizations to map out their job roles in the context of the organizational structure the general purpose for carrying out job evaluations using this or similar job evaluation methods is to enable. Hays methodology is the most widely used process in the world. I have found, the oil companies are using this methodologyi have also found some companies specifically asking hay certification in hr.
Job evaluation is a means of assessing the relative size of jobs within an organisation. It is a methodology of making job description and job evaluation knowhow, accountability all in detail. It is a scheme which is based on the points factor approach. Foundations h ay group pioneered the factor comparisonjob evaluation method and modified it in its guide charts in the early 1950s. Moreover, job evaluation methods play a vital role in the success of an organization by providing management power and systematic functioning of the hired employees. Hay guide chart profile method of job evaluation hay system human resource management services adopted the hay system effective july 1, 2012 based on a legislative study of employee classification and compensation practices. A critical analysis muhammad ali elhajji1 abstract this paper provides an overall insight of the hay system of job evaluation guide chart profile method. Aug 18, 2017 job evaluation and the hay guide chart profile scheme. It does not straightly determine pay levels, however will form the basis for an internal ranking of jobs. The hay guide charts are proprietary instruments that yield consistent and legally defensible work evaluations. In the eu using a job evaluation scheme can provide a material factor. This critique of the inappropriateness of the hay methodology for guyana is substantiated by the facts in the guysuco job evaluation report.
Provides participants with the technical knowledge to perform job evaluations and the value of job sizing. Our job evaluation method korn ferry hay guide chart profile method is the most widely used and accepted in the world and has already enabled tens of thousands of organizations across all industry sectors to create effective job evaluation frameworks. The value of job evaluationthe value of job evaluation job evaluation is an integral component of the work valuing processjob evaluation is an integral component of the work valuing process market rates matter. It answers the question of hay s thinking behind his purpose to develop an alternative and in his view more effective system for measuring and. Hay evaluation method human resources university of. Training in the use of the system takes several days. This method entails the comparison of jobs against other positions within the organization. Rolls royce, for example, used a revised hay job evaluation system to. The hay scheme measures the size of a job in job units i. Those who support job evaluation as a means of establishing internal job. The hay method is a well tried and tested job evaluation scheme. Internal equity workshop hay group work measurement.
The hay system is a job performance evaluation method that is widely used in north america and europe. Introduction and general guidance this guidance has been designed to help staff to produce an uptodate and accurate job description and person specification for the purposes of the hay job evaluation hayje project. Job evaluation can be defined as a systematic process designed to determine the relative worth of jobs within a single work organisation. Nov 22, 2011 in the end, a number of points or a category is assigned to each job. Look yourself to understand how job evaluation benefits your. If you disagree and value the job differently, you clearly dont understand the job. This factor typically receives the least attention and weight in many other evaluation methodologies. The committee is accountable for determining evaluations for all positions. Dear all, i am doing job evaluation for the company. It is a methodology of making job description and job evaluationknowhow, accountability all in detail. Durham university uses a job evaluation scheme to ensure consistency and fairness when assessing the jobs of all staff.
Despite these worthy contributions the criticism of the process continues. Job analysis, as was discussed earlier, provides jobrelated data, which would. When using hay or any evaluation systemthe input of line. This video explains the complex issue of job evaluation in an exciting but easy to understand fashion. Unison is fully consulted and involved and representatives of the union form part of job evaluation panels. If you agree with an evaluation request, youre only admitting to the obvious.
Job evaluation and the hay guide chart profile scheme hay is a proprietary job evaluation scheme produced by the hay group. Jobs and employees who perform those jobs are ranked from highest to lowest, depending on their quality and value to the organization. Hay job evaluation is a method used by corporates and organizations to map out their job roles in the context of the organizational structure the general purpose for carrying out job evaluations using this or similar job evaluation methods is to enable organizations to map and align their rolesjobs. There are three basic elements of job content common to all jobs. I document it here for human resource practitioners who for various reasons wanted to know how it works education purposes. A critical analysis muhammad ali elhajji abstract this paper provides an overall insight of the hay system of job evaluation guide chart profile method. Several methods of job evaluation have been used by different organization to establish relative worth of jobs across hay system of job evaluationis one of them. Download citation the hay system of job evaluation.
The hay method is the most extensively used job evaluation system in the world. The current, uptodate job descriptions have been moved to the hr portal which can is accessed via the herts for learning website. Apr 01, 20 the hay method of job evaluation according to steinburg 1992 is generally understood to be a point plan, although hay itself does not define the guide chartprofile method as such. Job evaluation and the hay guide chart profile scheme. Hay job evaluation has been operated in the county council for more than 20 years. The paper also answers the question of what made the hay system popular to the point of global recognition whilst simultaneously attracting its critics. A large percentage of this course is dealt with practical job. Advantages and disadvantages of job evaluation wisestep. Hay job evaluation is a methodology used by many corporates and organisations to map out their job roles in the context of the organisational structure the general purpose for carrying out job evaluations using this or similar methods is to enable organisations to map all their roles in a manner that delivers the following key benefits. Purpose of short profile in the hay job evaluation methodology, the short profile is used as quality assurance quality control checks. The hay group was founded in 1943 in philadelphia, pa, by ned hay. A job evaluation is a systematic way of determining the valueworth of a job in relation to other jobs in an organization. A criticism levelled against the hay guide chart is that the choice of factors is skewed.
The latter is also referred to as pay equity or comparable worth. The hay guide charts properly the hay group guide chartprofile method are the central instrument of a proprietary pointfactor job evaluation methodology developed by the hay group. Job evaluation is a useful technique, intended to enable trained and experienced employees to evaluate the size of one job relative to others. All jobs are evaluated not only by the interpretation of the factor descriptions but within the context of all other. Job evaluation process human resources royal roads. You would need permission from the owner of this tool to use it. Developing hay job evaluation calculator hay job evaluation. It is the most common job evaluation system in all areas of activity private, public, forprofit and nonprofit. Do anyone know or have the table of hay guide chart, please share for me. The purpose of this manual is to serve as a reference guide for the hay job evaluation methodology used to evaluate aupe positions at the university of lethbridge.
Undertaking job evaluation can be a complex task because of the wide range of varying factors that have to be taken into consideration, which is where our job evaluation tool can help. Employees and unions may be consulted, depending on the legal and employee relations environment and company culture. I have found, the oil companies are using this methodology i have also found some companies specifically asking hay certification in hr. Job evaluation has been a vital part of compensation systems for over fifty years. In the end, a number of points or a category is assigned to each job. Commonly known as the hay group method, the system. Thousands of organizationsincluding more than half of the worlds largest companiesrely on hay groups job evaluation methodology to help them bring together the right people, jobs and structures to execute their strategies. Hay is a proprietary job evaluation scheme produced by the hay group.
This critique of the inappropriateness of the hay methodology for guyana is substantiated by the facts in the guysuco job evaluation report which clearly state that of the nine 9 comparator. Oct 02, 2016 in the hay job evaluation methodology, the short profile is used as quality assurance quality control checks. It answers the question of hays thinking behind his purpose to develop an alternative and in his view more effective system for measuring and. Job evaluation is the means by which jobs are assessed against a number of criteria to ensure that all elements of the role are considered, resulting in them being given a score and grade. Jul 05, 2016 the hay job evaluation methodology is a proprietary methodology. The hay job grading scheme was developed in the early 1950s by e. Formal job evaluation schemes, especially the most popular method, pointfactor rating, have attracted a lot of criticism on the grounds that they are rigid, bureaucratic, timeconsuming, expensive, perpetuate unnecessarily extended hierarchies and ignore market rate considerations.
The hay method of job evaluation according to steinburg 1992 is generally understood to be a point plan, although hay itself does not define the guide chartprofile method as such. Job analysis should precede the actual program of evaluation. Hay guide chart academic dictionaries and encyclopedias. A job evaluation committee consisting of three hr staff has been established and trained in the hay methodology system.
The process of job evaluation involves the following steps. Disclaimer the hay job evaluation methodology is a proprietary methodology. Job evaluation needs to be differentiated from job analysis. Job evaluation process human resources royal roads university. The university selected the hera higher education role analysis job evaluation tool following a pilot of the hera scheme.
It was established around 60 years ago and has been developed and used worldwide by numerous organizations, in both the public and private sectors. Access to the hr services knowledge portal is only available to schools buying a core or full hr service with herts for learning. Available as an online subscription, or via our team of specialists, croner rewards job evaluation methodology supports the analysis of different skills and. Job evaluation hrc associates, management and recruitment. The hay methodology is an analytical, factorbased scheme, which aims to.
Companies are becoming unique in their organization structures, market niches and. It is the process whereby an organisation systematically establishes its. It tries to make a systematic comparison between jobs to assess their relative worth for the purpose of establishing a rational pay structure. In midst of switching from full hay je to using hay job mapping. Job evaluation manual birkbeck, university of london. In line with good employment practice the majority of jobs within the council have. Job evaluation is a thankless task, with the evaluator subject to criticism from all sides. Formal presentations, group and individual classroom exercises on the technical aspects of job evaluation and job sizing. Purpose the purpose of the hay system is to provide a consistent procedure to evaluate position classifications by. Before undertaking job evaluation, top management must explain the aims and uses of the programme to managers, emphasizing the benefits. This is matched against an agreed grade structure to determine the job grade. Introduction to hay job evaluation program purpose. Hay group guide chartprofile method of job evaluation it might be a merger or acquisition, new it can be applied to any kind of job at any level.
110 1568 1186 1016 1239 1120 811 303 1489 1019 660 1114 1217 1130 696 401 1359 239 1594 1196 1055 369 1354 406 1140 806 234 299 1262 1216 1345 273 811 333 88 297 303 1338